The Right to Remain Silent in Criminal Law
UK criminal proceedings state that any accused person should be treated as innocent until proven guilty. It is the role of the prosecution team to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a crime has occurred and that the defendant was involved. An accused person is not required to prove anything, and this means that there is no need for them to speak to establish their innocence. Additionally, all people have a human right to remain silent.
Recent parliamentary developments have led to a number of rules that result in a lack of response from an accused person to direct questioning from law enforcers to be treated as evidence of their guilt. The following article describes the right to remain silent more fully, including failure to testify, inferences and jury considerations.
Accused Person's Failure to Testify
The Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 has modified the historical right of a defendant's choice not to testify. Section 35 of the act gives authorisation to the court and a jury to conclude inferences from the accused's decision. This means that the court is entitled to consider a defendant's failure to testify or silence in response to questions as an admittance of guilt, should they see this as a likely and proper surmise.
The law states that an adverse inference can only be concluded if the defendant has received a warning from the court of the results of them not giving evidence or remaining silent, or if the accused has stated that they will provide evidence and then later refuses to do so.
In some instances, the law recognises that a defendant may be justified in refusing to answer all questions or refusing to provide evidence. This will only be the case for the following justifiable reasons:
- The grounds of privilege
- Because the evidence is excluded by another statute
- Because the court determines that the defendant need not answer a question
Which inferences can be drawn by a court?
A court can draw inference by a defendant's silence to conclude guilt only. This means that remaining silent cannot be used to strengthen a defence case but can boost a prosecution's standing. Section 35 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 sets out that a magistrate must summarise a trial with acknowledgement of the accused's failure to testify. In cases that are brought before a jury, the judge is entitled to direct the jurors to recognise and consider the silence of the defendant by way of determining guilt.
The Response of a Jury to a Defendant Remaining Silent
The jury can be given direction by a judge in relation to a defendant remaining silent throughout a court case. The Judicial Studies Board states that such direction should only be given when it contains details relating to the following:
- The defendant has the right not to provide any evidence, but they have been warned that their silence could lead to a jury drawing inferences.
- Guilt cannot be proven by a failure to give evidence alone, but acts of silence can support the decision as to whether the accused is guilty.
- The jury must acknowledge and review any reason that has been put forward by the defence team for the accused to remain silent. If the jury rejects the reason given, they may draw an inference.
A jury is therefore not entitled to convict a defendant based on their silence during court proceedings alone. However, when a defendant makes use of their right to remain silent, they must be aware that their failure to testify or answer can act as supporting evidence to a prosecution team.
Did you find this guide helpful? 0 |
Criminal Law Guides
-
Voyeurism Laws and Offences
READ MORE
Voyeurism is the term given to the act of a person obtaining sexual gratification by watching another person engaging in a private act without having obtained their consent. The law relating to this offence is set out in Section 67 of the Sexual Offences...
-
Burglary Laws Explained
READ MORE
The laws relating to burglary are outlined in Section 9 of the Theft Act 1968. The act sets out the offences that constitute burglary and how authorities can establish that a crime was committed. Unfortunately, burglary is one of the most common offences...
-
Cottaging and Cruising Laws in the UK
READ MORE
The aim of this guide is to help explain current UK laws regarding the acts of cottaging and cruising. We will explain what these terms mean, the legality of engaging in sexual activity in public and the potential offences and punishments that could be faced....
-
Indecent Exposure Laws and Offences
READ MORE
Indecent exposure refers to an offence that is recognised as a type of sexual crime, outlined in the Sexual Offences Act 2003. Indecent exposure occurs when a person displays part of themselves in a public place that is considered as being offensive or morally...
You might be interested in these questions
-
Can my curfew terms be changed??
I have just started serving a suspended sentence for gbh alongside comunity service and a big fine is a 3 month curfew. The curfew is quite relaxed 10pm-6am however I work as a plumber and emergency call out work can be a problem with this. I have heard the probation guys can refer me to the courts who can decide to take me off curfew and probably...
CATEGORY: Criminal -
I have someone living with me for the last 5 weeks who was on trial and on an electronically monitored curfew as part of the bail condition. His case was scheduled to finish by around 13th April 2018 but unfortunately due to legal technicalities a re-trial has provisionally been set for 26th November 2018. I am unable to accommodate him for the next...
CATEGORY: Criminal
- Latest
- Popular
- A Guide to Magistrates' Court Trials
- Different Types of Mortgages Explained
- Contract Exchange and Completion When Buying a Home
- Choosing an Executor for Your Will
- The Nine Stages of Divorce
- Child Assessment Orders
- The Role of ACAS in Employment Disputes
- What is private nuisance?
- The Right to Remain Silent in Criminal Law
- The Use of DNA in Criminal Cases
HAVE A LEGAL QUESTION?
Posting a question is completely free and we have qualified solicitors ready to help you. To get started simply click the link below.
More Criminal guides
Criminal Questions Answered
- Can my curfew terms be changed??
- If you have an ongoing case and the electronically monitored curfew is a bail condition, how do you change address?
- My ex smashed my windows admitted it in interview, but now in court he says not guilty. What will happen?
- What lesser charges might apply if Burglary can't be proven?
- How many hours can you be curfewed or tagged for? Is there legally a maximum hours that you can be held at home on tag?